CD-R or printed CD ?? I am puzzled !

  • Thread starter Thread starter Papoola
  • Start date Start date
P

Papoola

New member
Dear All, I am a bit puzzled now. I am actually mixing my first audio product (6 songs to be a 30 mins EP) and everything I have made is 16 bit 44.1 Only with digital multitrack daw.
As you can imagine I am in hobby with this and the commercial success is not forecasted. I only would like to have some acknowledgment from listeners and eventually some good comments around(hopefully).
The idea is to produce about 50 CD's to be sold and 250 to be
sent around free for fanzine reviews and as gift for electronic music customers( I have friend in some shops that will do that for me). In electro music the TOP quality recordings are not a must,and still lo-fi recordings are in the market made with 8 bit samplers, so I would not have the top top brilliant sound.

Originally, apart from the CD booklet that I would have printed with decent graphics, i wanted to make it on my own PC (plextor with+ CDR's) and run batches of 50 copies each to avoid unnecessary high stocks.
Then the puzzle started because someone told me to make a CD printed only because people do not like CD-R's. Then someone else told me that when doing printed CD you should have the best quality of the recording and high quality mastering is necessary to avoid throwing money for nothing.
Someone else told me that fanzine will never review if it will not be a printed CD.
One thing more about doing a printed CD; I should pay the glass master company before having the glass master done and I am not 100% sure that My Plextor could make the right "standard CD-R".
In that case would be quite a finacial failure, isn't so ??

I need help guys, expecially if people behaviour will accept to listen and review a CD-R !
Please remeber that I will defenetely do the color booklet and I would try to have any CD with its colored label and of course I will pay the copyrights to be on the rules!
Pls what do you advise me??,

PS.: being for free, if you give me you address i will mail it when ready. if you don't like it you would use it as frisbee , Ok ??
 
Well, for starters...if the mastering company is a "good" company, they should be able to accept it on any type of media (I presume you have it ready on CD-R). ;)

I also assume that you are making 2 batches of the same CD (50 for personal use, and 250 for etc.)

The company doing the CD replication could print the graphics on your CD's.

Or you could print them out and affix them on your CD's by yourself.

Instead of wasting the CD's by sending them out to US here at HR.COM, why don't you just convert it into a MP.3 format and then post them on the Internet. ;) .

peace...

spin

p.s. I hope you didn't QUADRUPLE post this thread..... :D
 
So you confirm people does not like CD-R !

Is it so ??

PS.: Only twice,this time and next time only one. But believe me , with 4 posts I got the amount of replies and point of view i needed, this time only your reply (but thanks)
 
I am not confirming a yes or a no.

To me, it doesn't matter if it's a CD-R or a CD, it's no big difference, that is when people send me stuff. My equipment can read both formats with no problem. But, when you send stuff to other people, you have to make sure that they receive the music the way THEY want the music. YOU want THEM to listen to YOUR music, so you have to go out of your way to make sure that they will listen to it.

Also, if you are sending it to people/companies that are in other countries, their CD players may not be able to read the CD-R's ( meaning the lasers aren't sensitive/strong enough).

peace...

spin
 
It's mainly the older CDplayers that cannot read the CDR's. The reflection of a CDR is less than 50% of that of a normal CD...

As for the CDR - printed CD question... I don't really care. A guy I knew that organized festivals found the looks of the demo rather important. Most people that don't record music themselves do, I guess. They have their priorities messed up. :) If you put a label on it, it looks good, so it's fine. I don't think alot of people care about the color of the CD if they can play it...
 
You can also get CDR media that is almost indistinguishable from mass produced CDs but they cost a lot more.

You can also print you own CDs but the printers are really expsensive and require media who's label side conforms to their printing method.
 
message to Jgourd

Can you ple be so kind to be more specific ??
Some people advises me Mitsui CDR . Is this the one ??
I am actually testing some Verbatim with AZO coating. They have a white cover that is claimed to be printable with special ink printers. What about it ??
If the media is more expensive I could make a small production (100) and in case of demand i could then decide to go for a CD print.
Good idea or not ???
 
There are two kinds of CD printer that I know of: Ink Jet and Thermal. The ink jet requires media that specifies that it is printable with ink jet printers. I think the termal will print on just about anything.

Here a link to a company that sells silver / silver media. I haven't tried it, and I do not know if these guys are any good, I just did a web search and came up with this link.

http://www.ioproducts.com/trusilcdrmed.html
 
Back
Top