Interface monitors and internet speakers / switching between

  • Thread starter Thread starter jtessmer
  • Start date Start date
J

jtessmer

New member
I have a Focusrite Scarlet Interface. If your studio is set up and running but you want to say listen for ideas on Youtube, are you switching the audio output on the computer? Using an external switch? Different speakers for the internet? Solo pc for internet in the studio?
 
Hi,
I also have a Focusrite Scarlet interface.
I set it as my playback device for all audio and systems sounds,
and my speakers and headphones are connected it.

That way any and all sound coming from the computer goes through monitors and headphones.

Is that not working for you?
 
I have a Behringer MONITOR2USB monitor controller on my desk. It has a built-in USB audio interface which I have set as my computer's sound device, so I can hear computer sounds over my mixing headphone and/or monitors. My actual audio interface (RME FireFace UFX) runs its main stereo outs into the MONITOR2USB' s analog inputs, and I have the option of mixing the two signals or listening to them individually on the monitor controller. This setup gives me the convenience of being able to use the same headphones/monitor for all of my activities without having to switch between anything, and without devoting any of my interface's resources to anything outside of my DAW.
 
I have a Focusrite Scarlet Interface. If your studio is set up and running but you want to say listen for ideas on Youtube, are you switching the audio output on the computer? Using an external switch? Different speakers for the internet? Solo pc for internet in the studio?
I’m not exactly sure what you are asking - do you want to match the Audio to a set of speakers? - I wouldn’t - just use the monitors that you have across all elements -
 
It's a bit unclear to me as well, what exactly is the issue or the question? You have audio set up for music production but want to listen to Youtube, so why can't you do that with the same speakers as the audio work?
I'm using two different speakers sets + headphones, usually using one thing at a time but sometimes in parallel. But I won't go into more detail before I understand what the issue is.
 
To the last two people that replied: I don't know how this works on Mac, but on Windows when you install an audio interface out-of-the-box, you only hear audio from ASIO-based applications that have explicitly selected that interface as the audio device. If you use an audio application without ASIO support (like a web browser), you hear that audio through your computer's built-in audio hardware/headphone jack. So unless you use special hardware or make some settings changes, computer audio is going to come out one set of speakers/headphones and DAW audio is going to come out another. (In my setups I sometimes use a USB headset for computer audio and my studio monitors/headphones for DAW work.)

One way to address this is to change the Windows settings to use your audio interface as the default audio device, which merges computer audio plus DAW audio into the same output. But this isn't great to do, since it can take resources from the interface and/or introduce some audio instability. And also, who wants to hear mail notifications while they're tracking?

As mentioned in my post, I use a monitor controller which lets me merge the signals outside of my PC, so my audio interface is still fully dedicated to Cubase but I also don't have to change anything in order to hear both Cubase and other computer sounds over my studio monitors; don't have to switch outputs/speakers/headphones, etc.
 
I too do not understand the problem? I have a MOTU M4 on a Lenovo laptop W10 and can play any YT, radio or recorded sound I fancy. If I run a file in Audacity e.g. it (and the M4) cares not which driver I use. WASAPI, Direct Sound or MME.
When I need to make "serious" recordings in Samplitude I select the MOTU ASIO driver. You only need ASIO for lowest latency. I guess other DAWs allow same?

Having Windows Sounds, those bleeps and bloops turned off is "Computer Audio 101" Circa 2010?

When I Skype my son I run HIS sound through the M4 (and Tannoy 5As) but use a USB mic to talk to him. All works splendidly without feedback.

Dave.
 
To the last two people that replied: I don't know how this works on Mac, but on Windows when you install an audio interface out-of-the-box, you only hear audio from ASIO-based applications that have explicitly selected that interface as the audio device. If you use an audio application without ASIO support (like a web browser), you hear that audio through your computer's built-in audio hardware/headphone jack. So unless you use special hardware or make some settings changes, computer audio is going to come out one set of speakers/headphones and DAW audio is going to come out another. (In my setups I sometimes use a USB headset for computer audio and my studio monitors/headphones for DAW work.)

One way to address this is to change the Windows settings to use your audio interface as the default audio device, which merges computer audio plus DAW audio into the same output. But this isn't great to do, since it can take resources from the interface and/or introduce some audio instability. And also, who wants to hear mail notifications while they're tracking?

As mentioned in my post, I use a monitor controller which lets me merge the signals outside of my PC, so my audio interface is still fully dedicated to Cubase but I also don't have to change anything in order to hear both Cubase and other computer sounds over my studio monitors; don't have to switch outputs/speakers/headphones, etc.
Oh okay, yeah, I'm on a Mac so things don't tend to require drivers, everything just works straight out of the box and universally: global audio output setting sits in the menu bar at all times, and it's each software's own settings where you'd separately make an exception to that rule. But for example, since I don't want that, my DAW outputs are simply set to "System setting", i.e to follow whatever that is at that moment. Some DAWs ask if you want to use the device as an output if you switch them on when the DAW is running.

There's software that allows managing audio routings if you want to specify which software sends to which output, but I'm afraid I have nothing to suggest for Windows.
But by the way it sounds, I would select the interface as a universal output, unless that somehow isn't possible and the second option would therefore be to have separate speakers for audio work vs. other stuff. Especially if you need to reference other audio content, go online for tutorials or inspiration quite frequently, it just doesn't seem very practical to not use the audio interface as the global output.
I haven't heard of using the interface as global output leading to meaningful lag or audio instability; is it a common thing in general or just on Windows? Also, it also must depend on how the interface is being used, i.e is it just an output device or is there also input and monitoring going on. There's also quite a bit that you can do for memory management on a computer, and the real hog should be the actual DAW; and how heavy projects people make varies dramatically.

And also, who wants to hear mail notifications while they're tracking?
Or, who wants to hear any notifications, especially on a computer where you can probably see the notifications because you're already sitting there? :rolleyes:
I don't know how Windows handles all that, but on modern Macs, in theory, there's now different focus modes that can be activated (much like on a phone) that silence notifications, or only deliver stuff in the background quietly in order to not disturb you during work, or only allow notifications from selected contacts. I've never kept any audio notification sounds on for my computer, except for some instant messenger, and that too only when the software is actually open. But recently in the world of distractions, I've had to go even further, and I occasionally find myself disconnecting the internet router in order to get work done; almost nothing is so urgent that I would require information on as-it-happens basis, rather than being able to check back in a few hours.
 
Another audio setup "trick" from way back? When running an external interface (or a decent internal card e.g. the M-A 2496) it was usual to disable* the On Board Sound Card. Reasons for this were, to free up PC power which was not as cheap and generous as it is today but also, along with disabling Windows bloops, it prevented the PC from switching the sample rate when an unwanted sound came along.

These days we have CPU grunt to spare and running ASIO drivers ( so I am told?) keeps Windows well away from audio processes? But if anyone has glitching problems these two old fixes are always worth a do.

*Best done in BIOS but Device Manager works as well.

Dave.
 
All my audio . . . recorded, or from internet sources (e.g. youtube) . . . goes through interface and to the monitors. It is a simple and practical arrangement.
 
As you said Gecko, all my audio goes through the interface. The onboard Realtek audio is disabled.

The only "issue" that I have is that I can't play a Youtube or media player at the same time when Reaper is active, as the DAW/ASIO takes precedence over any other audio. If I simply minimize Reaper (I don't have to close the program), it releases the audio for any other program's use.
 
As you said Gecko, all my audio goes through the interface. The onboard Realtek audio is disabled.

The only "issue" that I have is that I can't play a Youtube or media player at the same time when Reaper is active, as the DAW/ASIO takes precedence over any other audio. If I simply minimize Reaper (I don't have to close the program), it releases the audio for any other program's use.
Can you not "tell" Reaper to switch to another driver? WASAPI, MME. That's what son and I do in Samplitude.

Dave.
 
I could, but I want Reaper to only use the ASIO driver. I have no need to use the windows drivers. It's only an issue if I wanted to play along with a Youtube video and record at the same time. If I wanted to play along with a regular wave or MP3 file, I would just drag it into into Reaper . Since I have never recorded along with Youtubes, its not a problem at all. Besides, I have other ways to deal with Youtube videos.
 
Back
Top