I remember a thread back in the early days of the Cave here...I think it was Cl8ton that posted it...just to stir shit up
The Beatles suck. It was a great thread,
A thread like this is sure to get some divisiveness going on. Great is subjective to the perspective of the one defining "great".
I really like every one mentioned in the OP...just so many not mentioned of which some have been mentioned in the responses that followed.
Greatest artist of all time is another story. Greatest rock bands is what it sounds like the OP was speaking of.
The Classical greats, Mozart, Beethoven, Bach to name a few..The stars of the first half of the 20th century... Sinatra, Nat King Cole, Bing, Sammy, Les Paul, Gene Autry,
Move into the 50's and 60's Jerry Lee Lewis, Fats Domino, The Beach Boys and Brian stupid ass genius Wilson,
Then there's fricking dumb ass Elvis who holds the crown of the King.... That mofo was a legend.
The Doors, The Who, Zappa, King Crimson, Genesis, Alan Parsons, OIngo Boingo, Devo, The Clash, Oasis, Amy Winehouse, Janice, they all took us for a ride down different paths of the muse.
So the reality is Music is not a competition and what is good is subjective to the perspective of the one listening.
Notice I didn't name one single rapper..it's all about perspective I'd mention Eminen, Snoop and DJ jazzy Jeff and the fresh prince.
And as far as recently IMO there are a shit ton of really great known and unknown younger artist..
Taylor, Shawn Mendez, Adelle, Pink again to name just a few..
I was golfing a few weeks ago and I met this cat who's brothers are in a band that's been around for 10 plus years...They are huge in a small pond but no one in this BBS has ever heard of them..
We see and know what we know from the machine and what they shove down our throat and we swallow...the more that swallow it the Greater that particular entity is....
I think these cats are a great and breath of rock n roll fresh air...only now know about them because I met some cat on a golf course who was related to them.