Being the smartass that I am, I can't hold my tongue...(takes deep breath)
Okay, Here's the thing.. All of the nutsacks like you that say "what's so great about so and so, I could do that) Yeah, maybe you can play his licks or because you spend countless hours practicing your speed picking or hammer-ons or whatever it is you deem as "good playing" can do some stuff that sounds impressive. Doesn't make you or anyone else a great player. When it all comes down to it, none of it means shit unless people are walking down the street humming YOUR tune or have YOUR guitar solo still playing in their head even though it's been hours or maybe days since they heard it last.
What makes a great player is conveying emotion, and ideas that touch people so deeply that it is remembered for the rest of their lives. People like Clapton, Hendix, Page, Beck etc.. did it on a grand scale. At a time when music was shaking the world. Not saying that there aren't good players in todays scene....just don't knock the guys that did it first.