Kinda strange how these forums work.....
I've cycled thru dozens of speakers and pedals, and maybe half a dozen amps in the last 3-4 years. Near the end of my current tone quest I started reading threads at The Gear Page, after trying a lot of the advice I got from other forums including this one. I was surprised to find that the advice at TGP turned out to be a lot more accurate in a general overall kind of way than the advice I was getting any where else.
The point is don't rely on just one forum to find all your answers. Sure, there are several knowledgeable and respectable music chasers here, there's a lot of great tips here. But the web is the same price for Valve Jr people as it is for Dumble people, so there is no excuse for not checking out what other forums have to say. For example, I might be the first one to tell you, "Fuggedabout
the Bad Monkey, pure P.O.S!" because it is common knowledge that the Bad Monkey really IS a pure P.O.S. pedal. But I will never again say anything like a blanket, "Forget about EQ pedals." If you heard my current amp with and without the Allums modded GE7 EQ pedal in the fx loop, you would tell me to never turn that EQ pedal off cuz it sounds fantastic. No way I could get that sound without that specific pedal in that fx loop. And there's no way a great studio sound will translate 100% of the time to a great stage sound.
I've been away from this place for a bit, and I'm surprised at how blanket statements that are just not true can be thrown around like confetti in some of these forums. In the end, if a guy is truly serious about finding his best and most inspiring guitar sound and gear, there is no substitute for doing the research and simply buying and trying the gear. Sell what you hate, mod what you like, get the best you can afford, and always remember that every single ingredient from strings and pickups, every pedal, amp settings, all the way to the speaker and the cab and the room and the mic EACH will have an impact on the tone you hear. If you change even one thing, you have to redial everything and try your darndest to get good tone from it before you dismiss any piece of gear as useless or noisy or just plain POS.
Except if it's a Bad Monkey......those can go straight from store shelf to trash can!
I'd say you are a great candidate for a Mesa amp. Best amp I've had for plugging in direct with no pedals is the Mesa Express. The Frenzel is awesome too, but it has to be cranked full volume to work without pedals. Sounds great that way, like any real Fender would, and that is my favorite way to play, but it's hard to find venues that will tolerate that level of sound.