For AGC: Yeah, agreed on the old stuff. Gimme the old Ben E. King stuff any day
. And I like mine rather dryer than some of the newer, more polished stuff like The Nylons do, for example. Though I can't say that their level of reverb is necessarily detrimental; They still sound fine. Just "newer" than the old school stuff.
And one might be suprised if they haven't heard that early old school, Atlantic Drifters/Coasters stuff with engineer's ears in a while, just how much more verb is in there than what one may remember. The Drifters recorded "Up On The Roof" for Atlantic around 1961 or 62 (give or take a year?), and that is actually fairly well loaded with reverb if you go back and listen to it now. Same with "Under The Boardwalk", "There Goes My Baby", and many others.
And then of course there's that little ol' uber-standard; the 1961 RCA recording of the Tokens' "The Lion Sleeps Tonight". That puppy is wet enough to irrigate a 36-hole golf course!
It's interesting how sometimes what we hear now can be different from what we remember hearing back in the day. If a few years ago you asked me how much verb any of those songs had on the vocals, I would have said very little, if any. But when I listened to them again for the first time since I was a young-un, in prep for tracking someone, I was quite suprised at just how processed much of that "old school" stuff actually is.
For Walters: Walters, I'm not being a smart aleck here; this is a sincere proposition: let me throw those questions right back at ya. Re-read my original description. You've been around this board long enough and asked about a lot more sophisticated stuff than that. All the info you need to answer your questions is contained in my description. Based upon that and your knowledge of gear and technique, how would YOU do it? What would make sense to you? I'll bet you you already know or at least can figure out a set of good answers.
G.