If the US expansion west happened today, or in the last 100 years, it would absolutely be the same situation. We have the benefit of more time having passed. Israel probably will too in a couple hundred years.
What Iāve said here is that Israel needs to acknowledge they have taken land, and denounce that they have some right to it. Britain did not have the right to grant them the land. The US has admitted their wrongs and made some reparations to the native Americans. Any peace has to begin with that.
Iāll just add a little bit to this perspective.
I live in an area where thereās a high Native American population compared to other regions. Ive gotten to know many of the locals including some of the elders.
Despite them assimilating, having the same rights as the rest of us, getting some federal perks, they are still pissed! Royally pissed. It lies dormant for the most part because theyāre outnumbered. What can they do?
Theyāre now a minority in the land of their forefathers. Theyāve suffered unbelievable atrocities, the stories of which get passed down from generation to generation.
Even as recently as 30 years ago the federal government broke a treaty made for a reservation of about 250 acres that was fully inhabited. The Feds decided they wanted that land back, and evicted all the inhabitants military swat team style in the middle of the night.
All the homes are gone, long since bulldozed with the only evidence left of people ever living there are some one lane roads.
Itās empty and fenced off but used for nothing. Iāve met some people that experienced that expulsion as kids.
If one didnāt know the history of the area, and it wasnāt for the occasional federally funded Indian museum, and the casino, youād never know of the tribes that lived here.
Not only have the people been genocided but their history has been wiped out.
So yes, these people are pissed off. But what can they do?? Might makes right seems to have been the mantra in all of history.
Incredible injustices and atrocities have been committed towards these people and they have been regarded as less than human.
But this was so long ago and the way the victors get to write history, how the āsavagesā are portrayed in Hollywood films, so many people know little to nothing. And donāt care.
Fast forward to present day. Gaza is being wiped out. Bombed to rubble. But Israel is only ādefending itselfā. Thatās the story weāre told. But thereās a history there that weāre not hearing and most donāt care anyway. Theyāll just happily digest the mainstream story and throw their support and tax dollars towards Israel.
But make no mistake, a genocide is occurring right now and has been for about 75 years.
But might makes right, and history is written by the victors.