I really hated Eric Clapton's muffled tone in the 90s, I don't know what the hell he was doing, but it was muffled and buzzy and sounded like a shitty amp (in my opinion). I really liked his sound in Cream, and With the bluesbreakers. But that's an older type of sound, and I learned to love the "crappiness" of older sound.
I know I'm going to sound like an idiot, but SRV's sound still gives me goosebumps, even after listening to him for so long, I just can't get tired of it. (Meaning, I absolutely love it).
I like Satriani's sound on the Flying in a Blue Dream, but it can get tiring if you listen to it too much.
Oh wait, I'm supposed to state who I hate.
I have to agree with who ever said Randy Rhoads' sound with Ozzy, that sound makes me cringe, I really don't understand how they could have thought that sounded good to anyone. Waaaaaaaaaaaaay too thin for my liking.
As much as I love AC/DC, I was dissapointed with the guitar tones in Blow Up Your Video (yeah, I know, I know) ... but it was way too smooth, (and the drums sounded too "loose").
Who else ... hmmmmmmm
A lot of the SRV immitators have a very, how shall I say, offensive sound. Chris Duarte is TOO thin and pinchy, Kenny Wayne too dry ...
Can't think of any more right now ...