Doug H
I'll be there
The only decent sounds I've ever gotten out of a pedal had a lot to do with some crappy amp been driven pretty hard, in this regard the Boss DS-1 rules. I know there's two camps on this one, but it's a great pedal to have in your case when you don't know what you're going to have to play through.
For just the sound of the pedal, like direct in or through a good clean amp, I'd probably go with the old yellow Boss Overdrive, or OD-1 whatever. It doesn't try too hard to be anything special and is at least usable in my opinion.
The tube screamer wasn't too bad, it had a phycadelic edge to it that was pretty cool. Kind of thin sounding at the higher gain settings if I remember right.
They're all old pedals, but it's been a while since I bought any pedals.
For just the sound of the pedal, like direct in or through a good clean amp, I'd probably go with the old yellow Boss Overdrive, or OD-1 whatever. It doesn't try too hard to be anything special and is at least usable in my opinion.
The tube screamer wasn't too bad, it had a phycadelic edge to it that was pretty cool. Kind of thin sounding at the higher gain settings if I remember right.
They're all old pedals, but it's been a while since I bought any pedals.