The E-MU 1820 has far more features than the other cards mentioned. All mic preamps sound different, you use what you prefer. The 1820 IS made by Creative, I don't know if that is a good or bad thing. I know someone with a 1820 and his demos sounded very good, very clean and quiet. Other than the low mic preamp gain (40 db), perhaps the 1820 is a better choice for you. Go for it.