NationalSandwic said:eep... the idea of rhyming dictionaries freaks me out. i don't think you should need them... but, each to his own...
NationalSandwic said:eep... the idea of rhyming dictionaries freaks me out. i don't think you should need them... but, each to his own...
Cheeky Monkey said:IMO, a rhyming dictionary is just another tool in the kit, to use as one sees fit. Despite what some "purists" may say, using a dictionary (rhyming or otherwise) doesn't mean one is any less of a writer. I speculate that many hit songs were written with the writer's use of a rhyming dictionary.
NationalSandwic said:i'm not a purist. and for sure, hit songs have been written with rhyming dictionaries, i'm sure. no, it doesn't mean you're less of a writer, but i think it does imply (so, it's not necessarily true) that you're not naturally going with what your heart and mind knows. and you should be speaking your heart and mind. imho.
NationalSandwic said:Hmmm... I just realised that I'm not sure exactly what people's ambitions are on this board. If you just want to write songs for the fun of it, then sure, do as you please. But if you'd like to have a professional career writing (and perhaps performing) songs, then I think you need to show some serious natural talent. Sad as it is, some people are born gifted and some aren't. That's why they get paid the big bucks, 'cos they're rare.
Aaron, comparing using dictionaries to buying beef doesn't work. Beef is a natural, consumable/disposable/replaceable good, and not very important. Songs are constructed, and should be meaningful, not disposable/replacable. If you are writing those sorts of songs, don't expect people to buy into them. If you want to continue with the buying-as-cheating analogy, then I'd say this: Would you not think that buying your rhymes from a bookstore is cheating?
Jagular said:... I rarely use a rhyming dictionary. But on occasion it is a help. It is a tool. Even the pros (people who make a living at songwriting) use them. Why not use one? It sounds kind of silly not to if it helps you write. If it dosn't help you, then don't use it, but don't disparage the folks who use them and use them successfully in their songwriting careers. It is certainly possible to have serious talent and use a rhyming dictionary.
NationalSandwic said:I think we're talking at cross-purposes here. I'm interested in songwriters who write in a certain style. And I'm interested in songs and music that do certain things. Some of the paint-by-numbers stuff that goes on in this forum really runs against what I like.
So I'd best say: I don't like the use of dictionaries for me personally; I think it detracts from my writing process. I certainly don't need a spell-checker and a thesaurus to get me through my writing (which is not limited to songs). I won't use rhyming dictionaries (even if it seems I'm not able to do it otherwise), because it would go against how I feel music should be made.
So, certainly, it's your own perogative.
brummygit, I'm not saying you're talentless. I'm saying that there are people out there who don't use these sometimes helpful tools.