James Argo said:
I've used ReValver for long time. It's great guitar effect plugin indeed, but I agree that Amplitube blows ReValver away. It's cheaper (now), has better GUI, easier, and off course, the sound is the main factor...
... for sure nothing beats POD
I tried Revalver, and am not overly impressed with any of these in-the-box modellers. I need to
hear the tone and effects I am getting as I play it to play properly, and with Revalver, the latency was too much, even 10ms was too much to play properly to. I then rented POD, V-amp, and several other modellers to try out, and liked being able to hear it as I played it. I could run my guitar to a splitter box, send one lead to the modeller so I could hear it, and the other one got recorded clean (allowing me to try new patches after the fact). That was a great improvement. I ended up opting for the Johnson J-station, which I still use. 2 years of happy modelling.
Then I bought a 7W all-tube amp made by Garnet, and then I bought a 15W tube-pre Vox amp, then a 40W Fender all tube amp....I haven't touched modellers since as a real tube amp simply is unparalleled, IMHO, they are so responsive and sensitive to attack and dynamics, and micing options give you so many ways to capture a tone. I only use my J-station in teh FX loop of
my Fender Hot Rod Deluxe with modelling off, simply as an FX unit.
or I use it late at night when I can't make noise without waking the baby ("you woke him, you put him back to sleep"), and then I will record it as I work on tunes. BUT, I always end up replacing the J-station track with a mic'd amp track in the final mix.
What I found best about modellers was that as I began playing electric, I really had no idea what amp I should buy because it takes so long to figure out what your guitar "voice" is . The J quickly showed me that I am not a Boogie man, not a Marshall man, but that Fender and Vox were the tones that I responded to and played best with. Then I could start trying out real amps and keep trying new ones until I knew which one I wanted to buy. The J determined which tone I wanted to hunt for, a real amp made it happen to tape.
That is my personal experience with modellers, YMMV.