That was a very insightful response. Thanks for sharing.Time will tell about the circus and the wishing well.
Catholic raised, heaven sounds like a cool way to end this gig. I am all in for that wonderful happy ending. After many years of pondering the end, I'm getting close to the finish line. Crazy.
I am part of the church of man where we realize that we are living in a unexplainable miracle. Beyond our paygrade. Think an ant trying to pull off algebra equations.
Some of our greatest scientific minds have figured out of lot about what all this is that's going on.
My favorite "proof" that we go on is the conservation law of energy. energy can neither be created nor destroyed - only converted from one form of energy to another. What makes my heart beat, my brain work? Energy / Life. When that sperm penetrates the egg a unique and separate entity comes to be. The energy of the egg and sperm donors joins together to carry on. A miracle.
Probably about 9 years old I asked one of the Sisters where God came from. She said God has always been and always will be....But how does something come from nothing? Well that's the divine mystery....Hmmm maybe God can neither be created nor destroyed - only converted from one form of energy to another.
As far as heaven in the biblical sense I don't know. I observe that we are, and that I am. Funny that is what God told Moses when he asked what his name was "I AM". My best guess is that we are all "children" or a part of the great I AM. That we each have a soul / energy within us that does not end but rather gets converted from one form to another when we expire. We are stardust, we are golden, we are billion year old carbon. As Jimi once mused. We are in the process of evolution, almost at death with ourselves yet on the staircase of birth.
A few of my musings on the topic
I was walking down the main shopping street in my city in UK and there was this manic guy in the corner shouting to the passers by... repent sinners !! You are all going to hell!! This cool black kid walked past him and said "No man, going to HMV"Definition of Hell: To be stuck in Heaven with a load of smug christians.
Heaven and Hell are the same place. Maybe this is heaven.
Although there is a "Christian view of Heaven" it doesn't really gell or go anywhere. Christian views of Heaven are assumed to come from various passages in a few pages of the Bible ~ but there isn't really anything written in any of the 66 documents that make up the Bible that speak of Heaven the way "the Christian view of Heaven" is assumed to be or often portrayed.I don't believe the Christian view of heaven
The way "Heaven" has been portrayed by many Christians down the centuries, "boring" is being polite.sitting around in eternity and worshipping god - that just seems boring
In point of fact, when God "speaks" or some of the people whose writings are in the Bible write about the afterlife, it is in the context of a recreated Heavens and earth ~ 2 distinct planes.especially for God
Now......this is a biggie. I'm happy to, like markmann, talk about this all day and all night if anyone wants to PM me.I also don't believe the traditional view of hell - like God is going to punish people for eternity for 80 years of mistakes.
When you say 'smug' what do you mean exactly ? I ask because there's a slight implication there that Christians are by the very nature of being so, smug. I'm just curious if you draw a distinction between Christians that aren't smug and those that are. If you do, I'd be inclined to agree with you. But then, I bristle at smugness in any group of people. Of course, I also have to acknowledge that it's my definition of 'smug' and that might say more about me than it does about those I think of as smug.Definition of Hell: To be stuck in Heaven with a load of smug christians
In a roundabout way, it's not that they're the same place, but rather, the actual definitions of both "places" are vague and to be honest, mean very different things to the different people using them often, although, like 'love' it is assumed that every time the word is used, that there's always a shared understanding ~ which I find to rarely be the case.Heaven and Hell are the same place
If it is, I'd rather be in Jersey !Maybe this is heaven
Gotta love the humour of that kid. It's a bit like that old guy on the bus having a go at some noisy schoolkids, shouting at them "I went and fought in the war so you could have the freedom to make noise on the bus !!" and one of the kids turning to him and saying "well, then you should be really happy that that is what we're doing, Grandad !"I was walking down the main shopping street in my city in UK and there was this manic guy in the corner shouting to the passers by... repent sinners !! You are all going to hell!! This cool black kid walked past him and said "No man, going to HMV"
I dont mock the poor guy shouting, maybe he had seen the light or had depression, I have depression too and am trying to deal with it in the best way I can. My point is that just share the love and happiness and lose the anger and hate. Humour and laughing is the best medicine. I try to be happy and lose the hate now.. Hate and anger is just fear....fear divides us all.When you say 'smug' what do you mean exactly ? I ask because there's a slight implication there that Christians are by the very nature of being so, smug. I'm just curious if you draw a distinction between Christians that aren't smug and those that are. If you do, I'd be inclined to agree with you. But then, I bristle at smugness in any group of people. Of course, I also have to acknowledge that it's my definition of 'smug' and that might say more about me than it does about those I think of as smug.
In a roundabout way, it's not that they're the same place, but rather, the actual definitions of both "places" are vague and to be honest, mean very different things to the different people using them often, although, like 'love' it is assumed that every time the word is used, that there's always a shared understanding ~ which I find to rarely be the case.
If it is, I'd rather be in Jersey !
Gotta love the humour of that kid. It's a bit like that old guy on the bus having a go at some noisy schoolkids, shouting at them "I went and fought in the war so you could have the freedom to make noise on the bus !!" and one of the kids turning to him and saying "well, then you should be really happy that that is what we're doing, Grandad !"
I'll also add this; if it were true that all those people were going to Hell, standing on the corner of the street shouting it at them isn't going to perk up their interest to ascertain if there may be some truth in what was being said {shouted}.
Open forum? Prime Time is an open forum that even guests of HR can read.I wish people that don't really know each other and basically only meet online could have these conversations of depth in an open forum and actually converse, yes, get passionate, even a bit angry at times, without descending into the kind of insulting rancour that we saw all too frequently in the covid, politics and Trump threads over the last couple of years.
But alas, we can't.
I have watched way to many Near Death experiences on Youtube...Anita Moorjani's Ted talk "dying to be me" on her death bed experience is astounding.
Read a few books on the subject to. Enough for me to comfortably believe it isn't over when were done here.
That and the fact that I have had multiple personal spiritual experiences / interventions / awakenings that leave me 99.99% certain we're all on an uncredible journey and when we finish here it's going to be a surprise for all of us.
If you have never watched this I encourage you to do so.
No covid no political and no Trump, its over. Lets move on?Open forum? Prime Time is an open forum that even guests of HR can read.
How are past covid, political, and Trump threads relevant to this thread?
facebook needs to know.
To the best of my recollection attending Christian Sunday School.....I can't recall being shown a picture of Heaven, but I do remember being taught that the "entry requirements" into Heaven had something to do with adhering to the Ten Commandments.I'd say that in order to "know" whether one is going to Heaven, one must first know what Heaven is and what the entry requirements are.
The song is a critique of how they were bullied and abused mentally in the Catholic school system. When Frank sings "you will never go to heaven" it was everything the bullying teachers would say to him if he did anything wrongTo the best of my recollection attending Christian Sunday School.....I can't recall being shown a picture of Heaven, but I do remember being taught that the "entry requirements" into Heaven had something to do with adhering to the Ten Commandments.
All we have is hope brother. Trust me along with all the cool things and blessings in my life I have failed many many times. I have made huge mistakes I regret. I have been screwed around, cheated and had shit stolen. I've lost a ton of people I love. I get knocked down, I get up again nothing's gonna keep me down. As I have mentioned before it's the blessings like my kids and grandkids that tilt the scale WAY heavy on the side of win. Playing with VH and Quiet Riot is a great bragging point when shooting the shit with buddies but on my scale of good and bad just a tiny spec of cool in the big picture.Hopes and dreams gone.