B.SABBATH said:
yeah I'm going to have to agree with Tex on this, I don't really think you know what punk is my man...
That would explain why your song has no resemblance to punk at all... try to say as little as possible... you will end up making it worse..
I agree B.Sabbath! What the heck are some of these people talking about.... They wouldn't know a punk song if it slapped them in the head... It's funny listening to there thoughts on it though... This is the type of stuff good punk songs are written about...
WEBYCAN, this song really sucks... I think my mom could write a song closer to punk than this... It has nothing to do with old or new, or dead or alive.. It has everything to do with good or bad..
If you compared this song to a band YOU think suck, like the Pistols or the Ramones, you could hear how bad YOU really suck...
I would be embaressed by this thread if it were me... Then again... I would never post a song that sucks as bad as this one...(at least I hope not)
read this quote,
"Ever feel like you've been cheated?"
Most everything you need to know about punk can be learned from that statement.....IMOP
Listen to some 'Husker Du' or 'Naked Raygun' or some 'Fear'....
I could easily write a punk song right now about people who think they actually know what punk is... you thought you could write a punk song as a joke BUT this song sucks tooo bad to be punk... It truly may be the worst song I have ever heard in the clinic....
For someone who sucks this bad, I would not be judging ANY TYPE of music until I actually learned how to play some...
Incubus, the Offspring, Foo Fighters???? If that is punk, than you are a musical genius..... and this song you put up would be the greatest classical piano song I have ever heard since 'Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata'
I'm not trying to take a shot at you, I just find it funny for someone who puts up a song that sucks this bad, and then offers there opinion on what sucks...
This song totally sucks... I have yet to hear a real punk song that sucks this bad.... This is the suckiest song I ever got sucked into hearing.... "Ever feel like you've been cheated?!"
For someone who sucks this bad, I would not be judging ANY TYPE of music, until I learned how to play some..
"Ever feel like you've been cheated?!"