riffy said:
Thanks Southside for that nice explanation. Do you think that I could achieve additional benefits from reversing that explained mic order. Like, putting the K2 in close above the hammers set to a wider polar pattern and putting the 012's 8 feet out on a 6-8 foot spread perpendicular to the open piano lid?
The interesting thing about recording baby grands is that no two of them sound the same and that no two rooms in which they are placed sound the same. Combine that with the sheer size of the instrument and one can never say that this will always work better than that or the other. I know you sai you have only one or two takes for the tracking, but any time you might have before hitting the red button is always good to use to test different positions and possibilities (without going apeshit about it, of course
)
That said, the K2 set to figure 8 might work pretty nice in the piano. What I like about having two mics in there instead of one, though, is that one has individual level and processing control over the bass and high notes of the piano, providing a little more flexibility in mix processing, that recording the strings in stereo sounds very attractive to my ears, and that when recording to two tracks, one can set the stereo width of the piano in the mix to suit the piece.
As far as farfield stereo miking like you described goes, that can be a huge advantage if you are recording in an incredible room where the stereo pickup of the room ambience would be a huge component to throw in the mix. But if the room is not that great, then the stereo ambient image is not all that necessary to get (one could always throw a stereo Lexicon verb on the mono farfield
.) The main purpose of the farfield in that case is really just to grab a snapshot of the "whole instrument".
So, on paper, I'd lean more toward 2 in the box and 1 in the room. However, that could all go out the window if the actual sound of the strings is so much better with the K2 inside the box. I'll take a fantastic-sounding mono piano track over OK-sounding stereo tracks any day
.
G.