Well, I'm personally not a fan of Evans coated heads. Their clear heads are great, but their coated heads don't really act like coated heads IMO.
If you really want that vintage-type thud, go HEAVY on the heads. Remo Controlled Sound or Emperor X are 2-ply coated, heavy, black dot heads. Very "vintage". Pinstripes are pretty dark. Evans makes these oil-filled heads that are super dull.
Your toms are pretty resonant. I like that, but that also tells me there's room to tune them flatter. Detune the top heads until they almost wrinkle and see what that does. It's gonna affect the feel but it will also lower the pitch and lessen the reaction from the reso head. Then you can dampen that further with moongels. If you put moongels across from each other it really helps to dampen instead of just one or more moongels placed randomly.
If you really want that vintage-type thud, go HEAVY on the heads. Remo Controlled Sound or Emperor X are 2-ply coated, heavy, black dot heads. Very "vintage". Pinstripes are pretty dark. Evans makes these oil-filled heads that are super dull.
Your toms are pretty resonant. I like that, but that also tells me there's room to tune them flatter. Detune the top heads until they almost wrinkle and see what that does. It's gonna affect the feel but it will also lower the pitch and lessen the reaction from the reso head. Then you can dampen that further with moongels. If you put moongels across from each other it really helps to dampen instead of just one or more moongels placed randomly.