lasagne said:
Glen - would you think that unit was better than the Firebox ? I was thinking of buying the Firebox, but this is about half the price, so I may look at this.
I've not tried the Firebox specifically, but I have used a Firepod. But the distance in time and circumstances between the two uses is so large that I'd have a hard time making a fair comparison. I can tell you that at the time when I used each one, I was more impressed with the sound of the Tascam than I was with the Firepod (which I was rather non-plussed with); but that could have been as much an expectataions game as anything else. It's hard to compare apples and oranges from a distance.
Feature-wise, the Firebox has a kind of cool feature in that the headphone mix can be treated seperately from the main mix. Cool if you need to set up a cue mix, which you really can't do with the Tascam alone.
OTOH, the Tascam has much higher MIDI capacity (16ch vs 2 ch). Both come bundled with CubaseLE, but the Tascam also comes with Gigastudio software. Combine that with the wide MIDI pipes, and the Tascam is particularly nice for composing purposes.
Based on what I have experienced, I can't imagine why the Presonus should cost twice as much other than the fact that the Presonus is using a FW interface, which is a bit more expendive to implement and is easy to charge more for. When dealing with only two channels of audio, whether one uses FW or USB is really quite irrelevant from the perspactive of bandwidth and buss performance; there is far more than enough either way for two channels of audio, even with things like protocol overhead considered.
So the fact that one is FW and the other is USB makes no difference to me; as long as I have
a free port on the PC, I'm good to go either way.And if I am short a port one way or the other, it's a LOT cheaper to get a USB hub or Adaptec expansion card than it is to pay an extra $150 to get a box with FW instead.
So unless the Presonus sounds a whole lot better than the Tascam - which I cannot verify one way or the other, but I'd highly doubt it was THAT much better, if at all - or unless that headphone mix feature is a huge dealmaker for you, I'd stick with the Tascam and get the extra MIDI capability and composer software for half the price. And you're still sacrificing in sound, IMHO; the Tascam sound still beats anything else at it's price range, IMHO (YMMV).
G.