I think the BR is AWESOME. While it is true the learning curve for a newbie (like I was) is a little overwhelming at first, if you stick to it, it is really not that tough. I had NEVER recorded anything myself when I got my BR, however, I was familiar with the 'things' that are involved in recording music from watching someone else who produced a CD for me (I'm a vocalist). I am also PC savvy, so when I ventured into MIDI, that wasn't too bad. Having that background DID help me I believe. The BR is a great machine. I was in the same boat you are...not really needing 16 tracks. I sing, and play a little guitar. However, I wanted something that I could grow into, and the BR is perfect. I far surpassed anything that I thought I'd be doing on this machine, and I've had it a little over a year. I have seen other machines in the same 'category' (namely the Yamaha 16 tracker) and I think the BR is a better choice even though it is a little more expensive. I spent many LATE nights banging my head against the wall for seemingly simple things, but face it, this recording stuff CAN get complicated depending on how far you want to take it. Persistence (for me) paid off huge. Read and re-read and then RE-READ the book (repeat as necessary). Also, this forum and VSPlanet are very helpful. I am thrilled with the BR and think it is 'simple' enough for those who don't know much about this stuff, but 'fully featured' enough to allow that same person to grow into it and enjoy it for many years. It truly is a great machine. Check out some of my other posts here.....some of them have examples of things I recorded on the BR. I did all of em in my apartment, just me, laying down tracks of gtr, vocal, drums, bass, some midi instruments etc.
I don't really think you can go wrong with the BR, especially if you're just starting out.
Good luck
steve