Mick: Yeah man, it is a lot of fucking work, just to put together a song or two, just for kicks...Fuck man, I'm doing an album all by myself, Greg's helping me by giving me some pointers & suggestions on the drum programming, but the rest is all on me...But, I will say that this recording shit keeps me sane, sure at times I'd like to pull my hair out & scream, but 99% of the time, it's all I've got, & is what keeps me going....
I started the fake drum journey about 5 years ago, on a Zoom HD8, & to me, those were just totally useless...Sure, some people could program 'em to sound ok, you could even export the midi & use other samples, but I just could'nt get those fuckers to do anything close to what I wanted...So, then, I switch to the pc (Cubase LE4), & Beatcraft, which is kinda like Ez Drummer, just not as advanced, & IIRC, it used the "one shot" sample thing....You could load your own samples/sounds, but there were no velocity layers...Moved on to EZ Drummer & the piano roll thing, which to be honest, I spent a lot of time with, & thought I was pretty decent at programming 'em like that (up until just a couple months ago)....Wrong....LOL...Started using Jamstix 3 a year or two ago, but I use it for the midi out, to trigger my other vsti's....It's a really deep & complicated program, & would take years to master, if that's even possible...There are so many knobs/buttons/parameters to tweak, it's unreal...You can load different drummers (I just bought the Metal Pak, which has Neil Peart & Mike Portnoy plus a few more), that are modeled after their playing style/tendencies...You can tweak their limb speed, which determines how fast they can hit another drum/cymbal after hitting an initial one, all kinds of shit, & the results can be quite good, but again, it's a lot of fuckin' work to make it sound anywhere near realistic...
I've told the Gerg all the drum samples I have, here's the "jist" of 'em:
Superior Drummer (with 4-5 expansion packs)
Steven Slate Drums Platinum 3.5
Abbey Road 60's, 70's, 80's & Modern Drums
NI Studio Drummer
EZ Drummer (with 4-5 expansion packs, if not more)
Jamstix 3 (with the "XL" pak, & "Metal" pak, I don't use these sounds, just the "drummers" & AI (artificial intelligence/"brain"))...
So, I've spent enough on these drum vsti's to buy a nice, full kit, plus mics for all of it, a couple nice tube amps, another cab or two, & then some...But, I don't have the ability to use real drums (noise), so, this is the route I have to take....
Greg has been nice enough to listen to a bunch of my shitty songs I'm working on, & help me out by pointing out things that make 'em obvious programmed drums...I'm learning, but it does take a lot of time & work just to do one song...I've got about 10 songs in various stages of being "finished", about half of those are pretty much ready for guitar/bass/vocals...LOL...
Greg: Cool story man, & yes, there are a lot of fuckin' weirdos out there...It used to be away from here (where I live), but now, those fuckers are around...I see 'em everyday, & while I try to be a nice & good guy all the time, I wouldn't hesitate for one second to shoot one of those fuckers I'm talking about, if it came down to it...Again, I try to be a nice & good person, but some of the shit I've saw in the past few years around here, I wouldn't think twice about it if I thought they were going to try something on my family or me...
Rayc: Well, the song isn't terrible man, but IMHO, needs some attention in the mix....If you're wanting just the guitar tone opinion, myself, I'd try to change the sounds up a little, maybe use a different mic or speaker on 'em to make 'em each kinda unique...And, in the mix, the guitar in the right side/speaker needs a little less 'verb and/or maybe some high end eq, to give it a little sparkle/jangle type thing....On the overall mix, IMHO, the drums need just a little more vol overall along with the bass...Just my opinion, & trying to be honest & helpful, so please don't get all bent out of shape on me man...I don't hear the vocals being out of tune, but IMHO, they need to be re-tracked with some more emotion/feeling....I know how hard this is to do too man, so again, don't think I'm pickin' on ya or anything, just trying to be honest...