"Love Is More Than Therapy" (2nd posted song)

  • Thread starter Thread starter ODEKK
  • Start date Start date
O

ODEKK

New member
Hey all,

Thanks to everyone who gave feedback on "I'll Stay". I have incorporated the feedback and I think it's a better song for it.

This one's called "Love is More Than Therapy". Would love to hear the opinions of the board! Again, this one is tracked through my Tascam 1082 in Sonar 6 using mainly my MXL v67. All instruments played by the control freak that I am.








THANKS!!!
Kevin
 
A few nasty little comments ....

But before the nasties, I wouldn't bother saying anything if I didn't like the thing in general. It's a good song and you did a really nice job performing and mixing. Now the nasties.

There are a few things I absolutely hate because they push me out of the altered universe your song transports me to as a listener.

I'll list by minutes:seconds

1:21 the grumbling quality of your voice as you sing the "O" in "Love". Up until that point I feel transported as if I am on a drug. When your voice catches my attention the drugged feeling dissapears and I am back in regular reality.

1:24 Then when you sing "ya" after the last syllable of therapy I feel downright kicked ... (Yes, I am a drama queen)

1:30 - I'd lose the piano

1:51 - Same complaint as 1:24 except the word is "Care". I realize this is a very common thing singers do and sometimes I love it and sometimes I HATE it.

2:05 - I'll have to give this complaint a name, I'll call it 'Bogus' vocalizing. Do you hate me yet? I actually REALLY LIKE this song, otherwise I wouldn't have these strong reactions.

2:39 - Bogus

2:47 - Bogus to the Nth

2:55 - Here's a NICE little vocal flair on the end of the word 'been'. If it was less subtle I'd be screaming bogus while ducking for cover but instead I feel tickled by it .... Ahhhhh ... I much prefer to be nice

3:12 - I hate the sliding down guitar chord. I would also prefer the key modualtion that comes after that sliding chord be thrown away.

3:22 - I'll say it in a different way this time - The tinkling piano annoys me (Dayum, I am such a little bitch!)

3:33 - I agree that something is needed at this point but the piano doesn't hit the spot for me. I'd rather see some edgy lead guitar work like the lead singer/guitarist from 'Modest Mouse' does. He plays all kinds of horrible stuff and somehow slips it in under the radar.

3:40 - I LOVE your singing beginning here, The piano even begins to work for me .... maybe because it's not that high tinkly stuff

3:49 - "Ya Ya" works really well for me - I feel inspired and uplifted by it actually.

3:53 - I would say "Stop the words" at this point. I have been inundated with many words and now I just to feel. You could just sort of riff with your voice but I am now in the information overload zone.

4:11 - Sadly I must end with another instance of the word "Bogus"

Great job overall and I'd love to hear your comments on a few tracks I just did, I am so sure you can rip me a few new buttholes after hearing them.

Peace and all that good stuff
 
I'm trying to delete this duplicate post .....

I don't wanna keep two copies of this hostility out there ...
 
Last edited:
Back
Top