I think that's maybe something the OP will consider with time; You know how it is when you buy new gear. You wanna find out for yourself.
That being said, OP, if you're up for being drastic I'd agree with BSG in the long run. Sell everything and buy a simple interface.
A completely straight forward all in one box with a few preamps. It keeps life simple and you aren't committed to any compressor settings.
You can spend time manipulating your sounds at your leisure.