Event 20/20bas or Mackie HD824

[ruebarb]

I posted this in mixing/mastering, but it may have been the wrong forum. I'll try here.

Has anyone tried them both? I have Event 20/20's, but I think they tend to rattle a bit too much on low end. (I'm always hearing the cone make funny noises on the bass - that's what I get for loaning them out)

But I've read very good things about the Mackie monitors, so I'm wondering if anyone would ever choose them over Event 20/20's (I know they're about $200 more a speaker then the Event's, but prorec.com has the highest praise for them.)

RB

[trebles]

the day i heard mackies hr824,s i wondered how anyone could have bought anything else heres an easy test audition every speaker on the floor with the same piece of music select a piece of music you know well and a piece that is not too cluttered in the sound department having good seperation between all the instruments and sounds espp good clean bass punchy bass and drums see what you think

i,ll be suprised if you dont buy the mackies :-)))