Layla,Darla etc. vs standalone HD recorder

Roland Saul

Roland Saul

Active member
I keep hearing that you just can't get the same clarity of sound thru the PC-type recording cards. Is this true?
Do you have to spring the whole $3500 Canadian for a decent HD recorder?
I mean, the circuitry in the pc cards is "rated" pretty good for noise and
sensitivity, but is that just hype?
Does the PC itself really generate that much noise?
I've seen a couple of cards that seem great in the ad, just plug a phone plug right into them and clickety-click.
Yes, I am a brand new wannabe home recordist thingy-type deal, so I do not have a clue...
 
http://www.mp3.com/codyyoung
Not only can you get the same sound or better but you also have a heck of a lot more you can do with a DAW (Digital Audio Workstation)
There is no one wonder box that does it all. I have done some Very good pro stuff on Layla and with Logic and as far as noise, whats that? ;-) No you dont have to spend that much on a HD recorder at all. And no its not hype ;-)
The above recordings where done on PC with my honey Layla (4) that should answer your question.. good luck
 
They DO sound excellent.
That answers it all.
maybe the nay-sayers are all guys that put out the 3,000 for equipment that does the same thing.
HAHAHA

Thanks a lot, man, and by the way, the songs are quite nice too.
 
Stand-alone:
* plus: more portable; usually less "fuss potential"

* minus: Not as expandable... you're pretty much locked in to what you buy; Generally more expensive per track

PC:
* plus: can expand easily as technology improves; upgrades, baby!

* minus: generally harder to set-up; learning curve can be steep; on-screen mixing isn't as fun :(; possibly a nightmare if you don't plan well

Pound for pound, gimme a PC. But if you're not comfortable with the tech end, it's worth the price in beer to make friends with someone who is.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top