MOFO Pro said:My own experience is that equipment reviews in "for profit" publications generally run from Incredible (for the price) all the way up to just plain Incredible (but pricey)... These guys make there money selling advertising to the same companies whose products they review.
Honestly... when's the last time you read a review where the auther came out and said a product just plain "sucked"... They focus on the strengths, and bury the weaknesses... dancing around the real quality of the unit. You gotta take it with a grain of salt...
The fact is budget gear has come along way and much of it just doesn't suck these days. I read plenty of gear reviews that are not at all glowing. You'll often read things like "not recommended" or "there are better products out there in this price range" or "the reverbs sound harsh and ringy" or "Don't by it for the reverbs!"
Oh, those are just comments I picked out of two recent magazines laying in front of me.
BTW, I just went to the soundonsound website, take a look in the archives and you'll find plenty of bad reviews.