I have received a number of great suggestions about specific models to consider in an earlier thread (https://homerecording.com/bbs/equip...ews/advice-below-$200-powered-speaker-356438/). I'm wondering if I should address the broader question of whether I should focus my search on PA-style powered speakers or on "studio monitor" type speakers. I'm debating whether a self-powered "near field studio monitor" or a "PA speaker" is a better match for what I plan to do with it which is:
Listen to WAV files of practice recording sessions of a clarinet ensemble of from 3 to 6 players. Most practice sessions would be in a room up to 30' by 50' in size, but we would all be within 20' or so of the speaker. We produce some strong transients, so headroom is important. Looking for accurate reproduction of the frequency spectrum to judge tone quality of individual players. Don't really need much output below 80hz, but mids and highs are important.
Price limit is in the range of $150 to $200. It needs to be fairly light and portable, eg. less than 25-30 lbs..
Example of the PA-type I'm considering: Amazon.com: Behringer EUROLIVE B210D Active 200-Watt 2-Way Pa Speaker System with 10 Woofer And 1.35 Compression Drivercompression Driver: Musical Instruments OR Harbinger APS12 12" Powered PA Speaker | GuitarCenter
Example of the Monitor type I'm considering: Mackie MR5mk2 2-way Reference Monitor | GuitarCenter OR Behringer TRUTH B1030A Active Monitor (Single) | GuitarCenter OR Tannoy Reveal 501A Studio Monitor | GuitarCenter
What are your suggestions as to "type", studio monitor or PA that would be best suited. I suspect that several models are near hybrids of the two.
Listen to WAV files of practice recording sessions of a clarinet ensemble of from 3 to 6 players. Most practice sessions would be in a room up to 30' by 50' in size, but we would all be within 20' or so of the speaker. We produce some strong transients, so headroom is important. Looking for accurate reproduction of the frequency spectrum to judge tone quality of individual players. Don't really need much output below 80hz, but mids and highs are important.
Price limit is in the range of $150 to $200. It needs to be fairly light and portable, eg. less than 25-30 lbs..
Example of the PA-type I'm considering: Amazon.com: Behringer EUROLIVE B210D Active 200-Watt 2-Way Pa Speaker System with 10 Woofer And 1.35 Compression Drivercompression Driver: Musical Instruments OR Harbinger APS12 12" Powered PA Speaker | GuitarCenter
Example of the Monitor type I'm considering: Mackie MR5mk2 2-way Reference Monitor | GuitarCenter OR Behringer TRUTH B1030A Active Monitor (Single) | GuitarCenter OR Tannoy Reveal 501A Studio Monitor | GuitarCenter
What are your suggestions as to "type", studio monitor or PA that would be best suited. I suspect that several models are near hybrids of the two.
Last edited:
